Minimalist Coding

15 pages in this theme.

A minimalist approach to coding does not code absences
One thing which makes causal mapping a fundamentally qualitative approach is that we do not code absences. We do not think that the world, nor the piece of the world we are studying, is essentially a…
A minimalist approach to coding helps capture what people actually say
Encoding people's narratives about what causes what always involves a certain amount of modelling or theory construction. Most approaches 0130.0 Causal mapping approaches differ in application, constr…
A minimalist approach to coding makes aggregation easier
We just argued that 0130.1a A minimalist approach to coding helps capture what people actually say ((minimalist capture)). But even if you did succeed in imposing some special logical features on your…
Causal mapping looks for linearity first
Causal mapping most often looks for linearity first, while of course being on the lookout for feedback loops and circular shapes. Whereas most systems approaches do the opposite. Can you spot a comple…
Changes and states
When gathering primary data, the way in which questions are asked influences the meaning of the maps and their links. For example, in the QuIP [@copestakeAttributingDevelopmentImpact2019] respondents…
Coding context and mechanisms
Summary In evaluation work, people often make context dependent causal claims: “When X holds, A leads to B.” If you code only “A → B”, you may lose what makes the claim true in this setting . This pag…
Coding packages of links
Coding packages Start with minimalist causal mapping Causal mapping is a way of analysing what people say about causes. Wherever someone claims that one thing influences another, we code that claim as…
In a causal mapping dataset there is no need for a special table of factors
If you are interested in how to formalise causal mapping or in building software, we'd like to share this insight. If you are not, ignore this. Factors are implied by links We don't need to have a sep…
In-vain links
In vain links This note is for anyone coding causal claims, by hand or by checking what an AI has coded, who meets sentences like "despite the extra lessons, her grades did not improve". It sets out h…
Minimalist coding for causal mapping
Steve Powell¹, Fiona Remnant², James Copestake² and Gabriele Caldas¹ ¹ Causal Map Ltd; ² Bath Social and Development Research Abstract This working paper explains our Minimalist / Barefoot approach to…
Our approach clearly distinguishes evidence from facts and does not automatically warrant causal inferences
From Better Evaluation. Causal mapping distinguishes carefully between evidence for a causal link and the causal link itself. It does not provide any specific way to make causal inferences from one to…
Our approach is minimalist – factors are not variables
Many or most causal mapping approaches, including Causal Loop Diagrams, also code the perceived strength of a causal link. This means that the factors become variables which can take values between, s…
Our approach is minimalist – we code only bare causation
Why we stick to bare causation in causal mapping. Our rule of thumb: record only that “C causes D.” No coding of necessity, non linearity, moderators, or strength. Just who said what causes what. The…
Our approach is minimalist – we do not code the strength of a link
At Causal Map, we do not endorse coding the strength of causal links. You can't really do it in the Causal Map app (see 700 Coding with and using link metadata ((link metadata))). Three types of objec…
Plain coding
Summary Causal mapping doesn’t usually deal with the kind of non causal themes which are the focus of ordinary QDA (like in NVivo!). However sometimes it can be really useful to be able to simply note…